Events:CTK-Workshop-Chicago-2009 - Revision history

MarcoNolden: /* Towards a European project submission (Olivier) */

2009-11-29T22:12:51Z

Towards a European project submission (Olivier)

MarcoNolden at 22:01, 29 November 2009

2009-11-29T22:01:59Z

MarcoNolden at 21:56, 29 November 2009

2009-11-29T21:56:46Z

MarcoNolden: /* Lunch break */

2009-11-29T21:42:00Z

Lunch break

Ivoiwolf: /* hacker meeting */

2009-11-29T19:07:02Z

hacker meeting

Ivoiwolf: /* Package system */

2009-11-29T19:06:32Z

Package system

MarcoNolden: /* Minutes */

2009-11-29T18:05:51Z

Minutes

Ivoiwolf: added slides on "CTK Layer Structure"

2009-11-29T17:56:10Z

added slides on "CTK Layer Structure"

Kikinis: /* Slides */

2009-11-29T16:21:09Z

Slides

Kikinis: /* Slides */

2009-11-29T16:19:24Z

Slides

@@ Line 137: / Line 137: @@
 ** agreements like everything is c++ could get broken
 * consortium is very mixed
 * discussion: medical imaging vs. biomedical community, include more partners?

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:01, 29 November 2009
Line 133:		Line 133:
	* Qt wants to offer infrastructure for development, get more contributions		* Qt wants to offer infrastructure for development, get more contributions

		+	== Towards a European project submission (Olivier)==
		+	* some participants of the proposal were not participants of CTK meetings
		+	** agreements like everything is c++ could get broken
		+	* consortium is very mixed
		+	* discussion: medical imaging vs. biomedical community, include more partners?
		+
		+	== Slicer Qt port ==
		+	* coexistence with KWWidgets
		+	* demonstration movies
		+	* HPM: uniting development efforts is important, hacker meeting has to happen soon
		+
		+	== SCR update: Patric Ljung ==
		+	(Slides)
		+	* TY: 1999 asked about hardware future, situation was pretty clear. Today the situation is more unclear.
		+	* LT: upcoming things should be taken into account for design
		+	* IW: GPU and things like that should become modules
		+
		+	==General==
		+	* LT: application hosting is not frozen anymore
		+	* TY: for the next ITK version a lot of converging ideas like in CTK have been discussed.
		+	* HPM: modularization / plugin mechanisms have to be decided
		+	* KC: starting with a common core, funding adds restrictions for the groups
		+	* discussion about common data format
		+	** common data type shouldn'n be compulsory
		+	** create a new type on the same level like the others that could be used
		+	** create common denominators
		+	** OC: CTK should not only complement ITK and VTK, it should be designed flexible from the start
		+
		+	== Next meeting ==
		+	* SPIE 2010, LT will set up a doodle for it.

	=Participants=		=Participants=

@@ Line 62: / Line 62: @@
 =Minutes=
 === Layer architecture ===
 * describes dependencies of toolkits, not meant as inheritance
 * discussion about dependencies between ITK, VTK, CTK. Unification or creating dependencies seem unrealistic. The topic is deferred since Steve is not present and he also raised the topic in email discussions.
@@ Line 107: / Line 108: @@
 == Blueberry Presentation ==
+[http://www.mitk.org/wiki/OpenCherry BlueBerry] (Sascha)
 * PL: unloading of plugins and services would be useful
 * versioning of plugins is a strength but the CTK core should have stable interfaces
@@ Line 118: / Line 119: @@
 == Lunch break ==
-== Slicer presentation ==
+== Slicer==
 * Plugin version compatibility is checked by recompiling and using dashboards, matching plugins are provided with an extension manager in the slicer application
 * total number of modules is unknown, not everything is contributed back
 * decision what to put in the core: a lot of experience necessary
 =Participants=

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:42, 29 November 2009
Line 117:		Line 117:

	== Lunch break ==		== Lunch break ==
		+
		+	== Slicer presentation ==
		+	* Plugin version compatibility is checked by recompiling and using dashboards, matching plugins are provided with an extension manager in the slicer application
		+	* total number of modules is unknown, not everything is contributed back
		+	* decision what to put in the core: a lot of experience necessary

	=Participants=		=Participants=

@@ Line 94: / Line 94: @@
 === hacker meeting ===
-* HPM: Steve Pieper should organize it, week beginning of 22nd February or 1st of March. 10 people for a week, 1-2 persons per team. goal: produce some lines of code (see Ivo's slides)
+* HPM: Steve Pieper should organize it, week beginning of 22nd February or 1st of March. 10 people for a week, 1-2 persons per team. goal: produce some lines of code (see [[media:CTKLayerStructure-2009-11-29.ppt|Ivo's slides]])
 * OC raises the question of intellectual property of the written code and visibility of CTK contributors
 ** RK: there needs to be an institution or foundation

@@ Line 78: / Line 78: @@
 * TY: packages can be mutually exclusive if they use special software or hardware
 * summary: this remains a very important and complex task
-* general summary:
-** we agree on a layer structure, but not too deep
+=== general summary ===
-** LT recalls that we agreed on Qt Core for CTK core in Heidelberg
+* we agree on a layer structure, but not too deep
-** mailing list discussion: it was proposed to use everything from ITK if its in there.
+* LT recalls that we agreed on Qt Core for CTK core in Heidelberg
 * summary: qt license issues: LGPL fullfills most needs of CTK, some issues need to be adressed:
 ** Qt should always be built seperately
-** static linking, template classes, distribution (see also questions page of Ivo's slides)
+** static linking, template classes, distribution (see also questions page of [[media:CTKLayerStructure-2009-11-29.ppt|Ivo's slides]])
 * OC: nobody wants to inherit from another toolkit forever
 * SZ: advantages of Qt: scripting, meta-object / reflection system.
 * OC: CTK should provide means for converting / adapting to Kitware mechanisms / classes
-* summary: one CTK module, but not part of the core, provides mechanisms for common data exchange / conversion.
+* IW: CTK core should provide some common basic features; glueing mechanisms should rather be part of an optional module
 * summary: one CTK module, but not part of the core, provides mechanisms for common data exchange / conversion.
 === hacker meeting ===

@@ Line 29: / Line 29: @@
 *Select a logo
 ** http://www.commontk.org/cgi-bin/trac.cgi
+** Comments:
-Comments:
+*** too busy for such a plain background
-** too busy for such a plain background
+*** theme 2 preferred
-** theme 2 prefered
+*** logo 1+3 too similar to NSF logo
-** logo 1+3 too similar to NSF logo
+*** theme 2 should have a little gap between the C and the K
 * Morning: Modules / Applications
-** The CTK Layer Structure (Ivo)
+** The CTK Layer Structure ([[media:CTKLayerStructure-2009-11-29.ppt|Slides]]) (Ivo)
 ** [http://www.mitk.org/wiki/OpenCherry BlueBerry] (Sascha)
 ** Slicer Modules and Extensions [[media:3DSlicer-Modules+Extensions-2009-11-27.ppt|Slides]]  (Ron)

@@ Line 90: / Line 90: @@
 image:3DSlicerLogo-H-Color-424x236.png|[[media:3D-Slicer-presentation-June-29-2009.ppt|Slicer3]] (Ron Kikinis)
 image:INRIAlogo.png|[[media:MedINRIA-presentation-June-29-2009.ppt|MedINRIA]] (Olivier Clatz)
-image:Siemens-logo.jpg|[[media:SCR_CTK_XIP.pdf|OpenXIP Extensible Imaging Platform]] (Gianluca Paladini)
+image:Siemens-logo.jpg|[[media:SCR_CTK_XIP.pdf|OpenXIP Extensible Imaging Platform]] (Patric Ljung)
 image:Mitk-logo.png|[[media:MITK-CTK-Workshop-June2009.ppt‎|MITK]] (Hans Peter Meinzer, Ivo Wolf, Marco Nolden)
 image:WashU logo.jpg|[[media:DicomApplicationHosting.ppt|Working Group 23]] (Lawrence Tarbox)
 image:Igstk.jpg|[[media:IGSTK Overview - Cleary.ppt|IGSTK]] (Kevin Cleary)
 </gallery>

@@ Line 85: / Line 85: @@
 =Slides=
-November 29 2009
+In attendance on November 29 2009
 <gallery widths="150px" heights="150px" perrow="3">
-image:KitwareLogo2.jpg|[[media:CTK-KitwareOverview-Aylward.ppt|ITK, VTK, IGSTK, InfoVis, FARSIGHT, Maverick]] (Stephen Aylward)
+image:3DSlicerLogo-H-Color-424x236.png|[[media:3D-Slicer-presentation-June-29-2009.ppt|Slicer3]] (Ron Kikinis)
-image:3DSlicerLogo-H-Color-424x236.png|[[media:3D-Slicer-presentation-June-29-2009.ppt|Slicer3]] (Ron Kikinis, Steve Pieper)
+image:INRIAlogo.png|[[media:MedINRIA-presentation-June-29-2009.ppt|MedINRIA]] (Olivier Clatz)
 image:Siemens-logo.jpg|[[media:SCR_CTK_XIP.pdf|OpenXIP Extensible Imaging Platform]] (Gianluca Paladini)
-image:B3C.png|[[media:Pres_maf3_Heidelberg2009.pdf‎|MAF3]] (Paolo Quadrani)
+image:Mitk-logo.png|[[media:MITK-CTK-Workshop-June2009.ppt‎|MITK]] (Hans Peter Meinzer, Ivo Wolf, Marco Nolden)
 image:WashU logo.jpg|[[media:DicomApplicationHosting.ppt|Working Group 23]] (Lawrence Tarbox)
 image:Igstk.jpg|[[media:IGSTK Overview - Cleary.ppt|IGSTK]] (Kevin Cleary)
 </gallery>