Difference between revisions of "2013 Tutorial Contest Review"
From NAMIC Wiki
m (Fix MediaWiki table formatting issue discovered while converting to GitHub Flavored Markdown using pandoc (via https://github.com/outofcontrol/mediawiki-to-gfm)) Tag: 2017 source edit |
|||
(9 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
=Submissions= | =Submissions= | ||
− | + | {| class="wikitable sortable labelpage labelpagetable" border="1" | |
− | |||
|- | |- | ||
|'''Tutorial Name'''||'''1) Slicer Version'''||'''2) Platforms'''||'''3) Slicer License'''||'''4) Data anonymized'''||'''5) Contact Info'''||'''6) Tutorial Template followed'''|||'''7) Additional Instructions'''||'''Test Windows XP'''||'''Test Windows 7''|| '''Test Linux 64'''||'''Test Linux 32'''||'''Test mac''' | |'''Tutorial Name'''||'''1) Slicer Version'''||'''2) Platforms'''||'''3) Slicer License'''||'''4) Data anonymized'''||'''5) Contact Info'''||'''6) Tutorial Template followed'''|||'''7) Additional Instructions'''||'''Test Windows XP'''||'''Test Windows 7''|| '''Test Linux 64'''||'''Test Linux 32'''||'''Test mac''' | ||
|- | |- | ||
− | | Cardiac MRI Toolkit Extension ||4.2/Nightly || windows 7, MAC, linux ||No||Yes ||salma.bengali@carma.utah.edu ||Yes ||No ||No ||Yes || | + | | Cardiac MRI Toolkit Extension ||4.2/Nightly || windows 7, MAC, linux ||No||Yes ||salma.bengali@carma.utah.edu ||Yes ||No ||No ||Yes ||Yes||No||Yes |
|- | |- | ||
− | | Hello CLI: contributing an algorithm into Slicer 4 ||4.2.2 ||windows | + | | Hello CLI: contributing an algorithm into Slicer 4 ||4.2.2 ||windows 7, linux ||No ||Yes ||gcsharp@partners.org ||No ||No ||No ||Yes ||Yes ||No ||No |
|- | |- | ||
− | |SlicerRT Extension ||4.2/Nightly||windows 7, MAC, linux ||No || | + | |SlicerRT Extension ||4.2/Nightly||windows 7, MAC, linux ||No ||Yes(Phantom) ||pinter@cs.queensu.ca ||Yes ||No ||No ||Yes ||Yes ||No ||Yes |
− | |||
− | |||
|- | |- | ||
+ | |DTIPrep ||4.2 ||MAC, linux ||No ||Yes ||dmwelch@healthcare.uiowa.edu ||No ||No ||No ||No ||Yes ||No ||Yes | ||
+ | |} | ||
− | + | =Rules= | |
− | < | + | *Tutorial must be based on the [http://download.slicer.org/ Slicer4.2 current release version ]. |
− | + | *To enter the contest, you must provide a self-test that can be run in Slicer and '''a version of the tutorial that works on all supported platforms (Mac,Windows,Linux)+'''. | |
+ | Example of self-tests can be found in the RSNA2012Quant module of Slicer4.2. | ||
+ | *Tutorial and all of its components (data, powerpoints/pdfs, additional modules etc.) must be released under the [https://www.slicer.org/wiki/Slicer:license Slicer license] | ||
+ | *Tutorial data must be anonymized | ||
+ | *Tutorial must include contact information of the primary author (e-mail and phone number) | ||
+ | *Tutorial must follow the guidelines specified above and use the [[Media:TutorialContest_Template_2012.ppt | Summer 2013 contest tutorial template]]. | ||
+ | *If applicable, the tutorial must provide clear directions for downloading and installing additional modules <br> | ||
+ | +Applicants will work with the NA-MIC Training and Dissemination Cores in advance to do the multi-platform testing. | ||
<references/> | <references/> | ||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
#Cardiac MRI Toolkit Extension | #Cardiac MRI Toolkit Extension | ||
##was windows 7 32 bit tested? No test was run for it | ##was windows 7 32 bit tested? No test was run for it | ||
##video is a helpful guide, before and after pictures were presented well | ##video is a helpful guide, before and after pictures were presented well | ||
− | + | ##color of the labels | |
− | + | ##video | |
+ | ##with self-test | ||
+ | ##presented at ISRM 2013 | ||
+ | ##would be nice to have better instructions on how to edit the images | ||
# Hello CLI: contributing an algorithm into Slicer 4 | # Hello CLI: contributing an algorithm into Slicer 4 | ||
##add simple threshold name to end of download file instead of hello | ##add simple threshold name to end of download file instead of hello | ||
##no self test for tutorial | ##no self test for tutorial | ||
− | + | ##Hello CLI --->simple threshold | |
# SlicerRT Extension | # SlicerRT Extension | ||
##step by step pictures were easy to follow | ##step by step pictures were easy to follow | ||
− | + | ##very clearly to new | |
+ | ##with self -test | ||
+ | ##has many explanations | ||
+ | ##RSNA 2012 | ||
+ | ##ECR 2013 | ||
+ | ##Good explanation of very complicated workflow | ||
#DTIPrep | #DTIPrep | ||
##maybe have a page at the beginning of the presentation explaining what DTI and GUI are & if its "for me" | ##maybe have a page at the beginning of the presentation explaining what DTI and GUI are & if its "for me" | ||
##troubleshooting data sets to see which should be deleted and proceed with reduced noise | ##troubleshooting data sets to see which should be deleted and proceed with reduced noise | ||
##would be beneficial to have before and after pictures in noise | ##would be beneficial to have before and after pictures in noise | ||
− | + | ##no self test | |
− | |||
− | |||
− | # | ||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | # | ||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− |
Latest revision as of 04:34, 11 April 2023
Home < 2013 Tutorial Contest ReviewSubmissions
Tutorial Name | 1) Slicer Version | 2) Platforms | 3) Slicer License | 4) Data anonymized | 5) Contact Info | 6) Tutorial Template followed | 7) Additional Instructions | Test Windows XP | 'Test Windows 7 | Test Linux 64 | Test Linux 32 | Test mac |
Cardiac MRI Toolkit Extension | 4.2/Nightly | windows 7, MAC, linux | No | Yes | salma.bengali@carma.utah.edu | Yes | No | No | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
Hello CLI: contributing an algorithm into Slicer 4 | 4.2.2 | windows 7, linux | No | Yes | gcsharp@partners.org | No | No | No | Yes | Yes | No | No |
SlicerRT Extension | 4.2/Nightly | windows 7, MAC, linux | No | Yes(Phantom) | pinter@cs.queensu.ca | Yes | No | No | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
DTIPrep | 4.2 | MAC, linux | No | Yes | dmwelch@healthcare.uiowa.edu | No | No | No | No | Yes | No | Yes |
Rules
- Tutorial must be based on the Slicer4.2 current release version .
- To enter the contest, you must provide a self-test that can be run in Slicer and a version of the tutorial that works on all supported platforms (Mac,Windows,Linux)+.
Example of self-tests can be found in the RSNA2012Quant module of Slicer4.2.
- Tutorial and all of its components (data, powerpoints/pdfs, additional modules etc.) must be released under the Slicer license
- Tutorial data must be anonymized
- Tutorial must include contact information of the primary author (e-mail and phone number)
- Tutorial must follow the guidelines specified above and use the Summer 2013 contest tutorial template.
- If applicable, the tutorial must provide clear directions for downloading and installing additional modules
+Applicants will work with the NA-MIC Training and Dissemination Cores in advance to do the multi-platform testing.
- Cardiac MRI Toolkit Extension
- was windows 7 32 bit tested? No test was run for it
- video is a helpful guide, before and after pictures were presented well
- color of the labels
- video
- with self-test
- presented at ISRM 2013
- would be nice to have better instructions on how to edit the images
- Hello CLI: contributing an algorithm into Slicer 4
- add simple threshold name to end of download file instead of hello
- no self test for tutorial
- Hello CLI --->simple threshold
- SlicerRT Extension
- step by step pictures were easy to follow
- very clearly to new
- with self -test
- has many explanations
- RSNA 2012
- ECR 2013
- Good explanation of very complicated workflow
- DTIPrep
- maybe have a page at the beginning of the presentation explaining what DTI and GUI are & if its "for me"
- troubleshooting data sets to see which should be deleted and proceed with reduced noise
- would be beneficial to have before and after pictures in noise
- no self test